All Rights Reserved
AccessEcon LLC 2006, 2008.
Powered by MinhViet JSC
ralph lauren polo

 
Bharat Bhole and Bríd Gleeson Hanna
 
''An analytical framework for interpreting appellate court data''
( 2009, Vol. 29 No.2 )
 
 
The objective of this paper is to present a simple but flexible theoretical model of the adjudication process that can be used to derive implications of various hypotheses about the adjudicators and litigants for the trial win rates, appeal rates and the reversal rates. Such a model can serve as a helpful tool for guiding empirical work on attitudes and competency of adjudicators and litigants. We use the model to study how the appeal and reversal rates are affected by the litigants'' perception that the trial court has a pro-plaintiff bias. We find that such a perception can result in higher appeal and reversal rates for the defendants relative to the plaintiffs, a pattern that is observed in the data.
 
 
Keywords: Trial Court Bias, Appeal Rates, Reversal Rates, Adjudication Process, Appellate Courts
JEL: K4 - Legal Procedure, the Legal System, and Illegal Behavior: General
K0 - Law and Economics: General (including Data Sources and Description)
 
Manuscript Received : Feb 27 2009 Manuscript Accepted : May 28 2009

  This abstract has been downloaded 286 times                The Full PDF of this paper has been downloaded 87724 times